Small Talk is My Fault

How a sales course taught me how to have more meaningful conversations & deepen my relationships

My wallet, made by blueq.com.

As you can see from my fantastic wallet, shown above, I hate small talk. By which I mean: shallow verbal interactions where nothing important or memorable is said.

But this winter I signed up for a sales course at Mountain Hub, led by Sue-Rose Read of Oneberrie, and I soon realized: I’m the one perpetuating the small talk. It’s my own fault.

And, more importantly: I can fix it.

Here are some of the insights Sue-Rose offered during that course. If you use them, they can transform your routine interactions too.

First: a look in the mirror

(As demonstrated by this very Medium story …) My default style is to “show up and throw up.” In other words: I have something I’m excited about, whether it’s an idea or an adventure or whatever, and I shout it from the rooftops, assuming that the right people will hear me and benefit from what I’m sharing. A classic Heather interaction with a friend or acquaintance sounds like this:

HEATHER: “Hi. Do you know about [my Passion of the Week]? Let me tell you all about it.”

Or, if it’s a casual interaction, like seeing a familiar face at the grocery store, I tend to comment on the weather.

Yes, I’m that person.

Partly this is because I often mis-remember people’s names, and because I never know what to talk to people about other than my own Passion of the Week, and so I try to mask my social awkwardness with generic chit chat.

When it comes to listening to other people, I am consciously working at this skill (my husband, Brock, was a fantastic listener), but my instincts are to point out the silver lining of a sad tale, or come up with an action plan to fix the problem.

This is not what good listeners do.

Sue-Rose’s secret weapon: questions

Listening isn’t just silently nodding as someone else speaks: it’s asking questions.

We can ask questions:

  • to dig deeper into what the other person is saying,
  • to steer the conversation in a direction that interests us,
  • to prolong the conversation, which gives us time to really think about what the other person is saying, and
  • as an exercise is looking outward, rather than inward.

Curb your instincts

In a conversation, maybe (like me) your first instinct is to:

  1. solve the problem;
  2. match a story/statement with our own story/statement (or, worse, try to top the other person’s story somehow); or
  3. answer a question, when it’s asked.

Instead, we can:

  1. ask targeted questions (“how did that happen?”), or say: “tell me more about that.”
  2. Meet a question with our own question: “That’s an interesting/good question. Why do you ask?”

I picture this sort of conversation being like a friendly hot-potato game: the challenge is to keep the talking-potato in the other person’s hands for as long as possible. To keep them talking. We (both) “win” when we really listen to what they’re saying, and ask good questions to demonstrate our interest.

Planning a conversation

For scheduled conversations, such as coffee dates with friends, a work meeting, or a family dinner, you can plan some questions in advance. Try to start a conversation with a question, rather than with a statement or by sharing your own story. (Or, if you’re like me, preaching about your Passion of the Week.)

Even small-talk-style interactions can be planned ahead: when you leave your house to head to the grocer’s, have some questions in mind. Instead of the bland “how are you?”, you could ask: “do you have any plans for spring break?” or “what does your family like to do in the winter?”

Why is small talk bad?

If you’re someone who enjoys connecting with other people, this “questions” approach takes you beyond the superficial: it deepens and increases the quality of your interactions, and of your relationships.

If you’re a preacher/cheerleader-type of person like me, who loves connecting people with useful information, asking questions allows you to better understand that person’s unique situation and needs. The information you might eventually offer will be more relevant and useful.

And, because you’ve connected with the person by having a meaningful conversation, they won’t feel like they’ve been preached or sold to.

Writer vs. good listener

I love my funny wallet, but I’m embarrassed by it now: I know that small-talk interactions are my own missed opportunities. My wallet has become a reminder to START with questions, and to be a better listener.

In fact, I’m painfully aware, with the wallet sitting beside my desktop now, that this post is another “show up & throw up” situation.

I’ll strive to demonstrate and practice my new listening/conversational skills when I respond to your comments. Please, go ahead: post a comment and let’s see how I do.

(Thank you so very much to my patrons for aiding & abetting my website & Medium stories.)

4 thoughts on “Small Talk is My Fault”

  1. Hi Heather,
    I’ve been reading your blog for a couple of years. Not sure where I found it but I saw one and liked the way you write and your back story started where I currently live so I was aware of you.
    I enjoyed this one as well, and see myself in lots of the stuff you say. But…..(always a but) I wanted to comment on your idea that simply discussing the weather is not deep enough or meaningful enough and that you plan out those meetings or snippets to be more meaningful by asking questions etc. I would put to you that not all interactions need to be meaningful or planned Here’s why. When we say “hi – hows it going” to someone in passing, or something like “great sunny day isn’t it” I find that the meaning is simply just acknowledging that either you know the other person, or if its not someone you know, you are simply acknowledging someone else’s existence. Either/ or can be helpful just by itself or as a little snippet.
    I know that sometimes when I’ve been in a grocery store and I have seen someone I know that I don’t really feel like chatting with at that moment, instead of making ‘meaningless’ chat- I have been known to go in the other direction. Grocery stores are big and easily navigable for this. Sometimes I’m I’m really happy to just say hi and move on, or wave from afar.
    Just a thought. Small talk doesn’t come easily to many, but I don’t believe that its awful. Some days it could save a life, as opposed to someone dying from it. Just my two cents. Cheers

    1. I really appreciate you reading these posts, and taking the time to write out your own thoughts, Pam. Thank you!

      I wish I could highlight parts of your response, especially: “the meaning is simply just acknowledging that either you know the other person, or if it’s not someone you know, you are simply acknowledging someone else’s existence.” That’s lovely, and true.

      Thank you also for saying that “Small talk doesn’t come easily to many.” I often feel I’m more socially awkward than “normal” people, and it’s nice to hear that I’m not the only one who struggles to think of something to talk about in these passing interactions.

      1. Pam — I was thinking about your comment while doing my errands in town yesterday, and noticed at least twice how my “small talk” greetings to strangers (“Hello” “Hello” “How are you today?” “Fine, thank you for asking”) was actually, obviously APPRECIATED by at least two elderly gentlemen. I think you’re right about the value of connecting in these small ways with others, and of “simply acknowledging someone else’s existence.”

  2. Great ideas. Thanks for writing. I’m also learning about the benefits of small talk. Or maybe medium talk. I am used to two modes of conversation, the weather OR your deepest darkest most vulnerable emotions. I’m learning that people who can hold a pleasant conversation for half an hour where we talk about their kitchen reno, their holiday plans, their new murder mystery idea, etc are extremely important. Not small talk but not big talk either.

    I think it’s about trust. Slowly unfurling layers of self.

    Just thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *